Infant Soy Formula — A Risky Public Experiment

Editor’s Note: This article is a reprint. It was originally published August 30, 2017.

The food you feed your baby during his or her first years has an enormous impact on their development and long-term health. I strongly encourage all mothers to do everything possible to exclusively breast-feed for least six months or longer for this reason, as breast-feeding has tremendous benefits for both mother asnd child.

It may even be a good idea to begin planning for successful breast-feeding before your baby is even born. If it turns out you can’t breast-feed, then you can’t, but it’s good to have an optimal goal.

La Leche League¹ is a great resource whether you want to prepare beforehand or find you’re having trouble breast-feeding once your baby is born. Also find out whether your hospital of choice offers breast-feeding classes and lactation consultants. If it doesn’t, you may want to select a hospital that offers greater support. If for whatever reason you’re unable to breast-feed, or you have adopted your newborn, donated breast milk may be an option.

Like the Weston A. Price Foundation (WAPF), I do not recommend using human milk banks, though, as they require the milk to be pasteurized. An alternative may be to work with a physician or pediatrician who is willing to help you find a safe milk donor, and who will be involved in a screening process to ensure the milk is safe. If neither breast-feeding nor milk donation work out, your next best bet is to make your own infant formula.

The Strong Case Against Commercial Infant Formulas

I recommend avoiding commercial infant formulas as much as possible, including organic brands. For starters, most are far too high in refined sugar for optimal health. Infant formula can contain as much sugar as a can of soda, and this processed fructose has none of the benefits of the natural sugars found in breast milk.

Instead, just like soda, it comes with a long list of adverse metabolic effects, raising your child’s risk for obesity, diabetes² and related health problems, both in the short and long term.

Most formulas also contain a number of other questionable ingredients³ — including genetically modified organisms⁴ (GMOs), synthetic vitamins, inorganic minerals, excessive protein and harmful fats — while lacking vital immune-boosting nutrients found in breast milk.

As noted by WAPF,⁵ since 1980, more than 20 infant formula recalls have been issued due to contamination with pathogens, heavy metals, arsenic,⁶ perchlorate (an ingredient in rocket fuel), foreign substances such as glass or melamine, inadequate nutrition and more. Compared to breast-fed babies, studies have also shown that bottle-fed babies have:⁷

• A 14 times higher hospitalization rate
• Double the risk of infant death
• Fourfold higher risk of sudden infant death syndrome
• More frequent and more severe upper respiratory infections and gastrointestinal problems
• Higher rates of jaw misalignment and related problems, such as breathing problems, snoring, sleep apnea and speech impediments

Nursing Versus Bottle Feeding — Beyond Nutrition

The video above shows the mechanics of breast-feeding using ultrasound. A vacuum is created when the middle of the baby’s tongue comes down, which helps express milk from the breast. Next, the forward part of the baby’s tongue pushes the mother’s nipple inside, right behind the two front teeth.

This motion explains why ancestral feeding widens the jaw, and pushes both the upper and lower jaws forward. It also pushes the cheekbones in the mid-face forward. Add to that restricted frenula, and the tongue, lips and cheek do not usually allow the baby to breast-feed normally.

The sucking motion on the breast essentially acts like a piston that pushes the baby’s mid-face outward. When a child is bottle fed, none of this happens, resulting in a narrow facial structure, poorly defined jaw and jaw misalignment. The anatomically incorrect palate and poorly aligned jaw bone also crowd teeth, resulting in crooked teeth.

Soy Formula — The Absolute Worst Formula

Among your absolute worst, most dangerous breast milk substitutes are soy-based formulas. A study⁸ published in Environmental Health Perspectives again raises questions about the safety of soy infant formula.

As noted by the authors, “Early-life exposure to estrogenic compounds affects the development of the reproductive system in rodent models and humans. Soy products, which contain phytoestrogens such as genistein, are one source of exposure in infants fed soy formula, and they result in high serum concentrations.”

The aim of this study was to determine whether girls’ exposure to soy during infancy might affect DNA methylation in vaginal cells.

As it turns out, there were specific differences between the cell samples obtained from babies fed soy infant formula and those given cow’s milk formula, prompting the researchers to conclude that “Girls fed soy formula have altered DNA methylation in vaginal cell DNA which may be associated with decreased expression of an estrogen-responsive gene.”

Soy infant formula accounts for 12% of the U.S. formula market⁹ — this despite lacking evidence to support the use of soy in infant feeding regimens. On the upside, that’s less than half of what it was in 1998, when soy formula had captured 25% of the market.¹⁰

Part of the problem is that the burden to prove safety is left to manufacturers. The U.S. Food and Drug Administration does not actually approve infant formulas,^11,12 although commercial infant formula must meet certain nutritional requirements.¹³ The agency didn’t even publish a rule on manufacturing standards for infant formula until September 2014. As noted by WAPF,¹⁴ “The ‘scientific’ formula label you see today is a result of years of guesswork.”

Of particular concern is the estrogenic activity of soy. Soy milk and soy formula contain up to 4,500 times more plant estrogens than breast milk or cow’s milk, and studies have shown serum estrogen levels are significantly higher in soy-fed babies. If you can’t breast-feed for whatever reason, the last thing you ever want to feed your baby is soy formula. It’s far better to use the homemade formula discussed below.

Soy Formula Linked to Troublesome Long-Term Effects

As noted in the featured study, soy formula — which provides an estrogen amount equivalent to at least five birth control pills per day¹⁵ — has been linked to a number of troubling side effects, including:

In an article discussing this topic, Pulitzer Prize-winning journalist Deborah Blum writes:¹⁷

“The idea that plant hormones — such as genistein, the primary phytoestrogen in soy — can interfere with mammalian development is not new. Biologists have been trying to sort out such effects for more than half a century; one of the first such studies followed the rather startling discovery that sheep grazing on fields dense with a hormone-rich clover could become temporarily sterile as a result of their diet.

Heather Patisaul, a biology professor at North Carolina State University who specializes in the study of endocrine disruptors, notes that similar effects can be seen in humans: Young women who consume a diet exceptionally high in soy also occasionally ‘shut off their menstrual cycles’ and become temporarily infertile.

‘When we think about endocrine disruptors, we have to remember that they aren’t all synthetic compounds … Soy is both a natural food and a hormonally active one.'”

Breast Milk Is a Complete Food

Breast milk from a healthy mother contains hundreds of substances, some of which cannot be reproduced or imitated, and over 100 different types of fats alone. A woman’s breast milk also alters over time, providing the child with highly personalized nutrition. Colostrum, which comes out after giving birth, is quickly and easily digestible, whereas more mature breast milk contains a long list of vitamins, minerals and higher amounts of fat.

Importantly, while breast milk contains sugars, they bear no resemblance to processed corn-based sugars whatsoever. For example, breast milk contains about 150 different oligosaccharides — complex chains of sugars that are completely unique to human milk. These sugars are indigestible. Their primary purpose is to nourish healthy gut microbes, thereby optimizing the child’s gut health and strengthening the immune system.

Breast milk also contains nutrient growth factors¹⁸ and antibodies (immune molecules) that provide the baby with natural immunity to illnesses the mother is immune to. This is why breast-fed babies tend to have far fewer colds than formula fed babies.

Moreover, when a newborn is exposed to a pathogen, he or she will transfer it back to the mother while nursing. The mother will then make antibodies to that particular germ and transfer them back to the baby at the next feeding, thereby speeding up the recovery process and promoting future immunity toward the organism, should it be encountered again.

Healthy Options for Mothers Who Cannot Breast-Feed

If you cannot breast-feed, your best bet is to make your own homemade infant formula using raw milk. In the video above, Sarah Pope discusses the differences between different kinds of milk, such as cow’s milk and goat’s milk, and why cow’s milk is actually preferable. She then demonstrates how to make two different formulas, including a meat-based formula for infants with milk allergy.

Pope, who runs The Healthy Home Economist website, is a member of the WAPF board of directors. If you’re unsure of where to obtain organic, raw grass fed milk, visit RealMilk.com. Ideally, you’ll want to make fresh formula every day. It can be safely frozen, though, so you could make a larger batch to last a few days.

Milk-Based Formula Recipe and Instructions

The following raw cow’s milk recipe will yield 36 ounces of formula. In her video,¹⁹ Pope also makes a number of substitute suggestions for various circumstances such as allergy to certain ingredients, indigestion or constipation. In the event a baby does better on raw goat milk — a frequent occurrence as the protein is A2 casein — a modification of the ingredients²⁰ is necessary to adjust for the nutritional differences:

A Note on Milk Proteins

The next recipe Pope demonstrates is for a meat-based formula using liver, suitable for babies who cannot tolerate milk. Keep in mind that many symptoms of milk intolerance are caused by A1 casein, a type of lectin associated with leaky gut and autoimmune disorders. Casein A2 is the normal protein in milk, present in sheep, goat, water buffalo and some Jersey cow milk. Unfortunately, most cows today are casein A1 producers.

The A1 protein is metabolized in your gut to make beta-casomorphin, which can attach to the beta cell of your pancreas and incite an autoimmune attack. Many who believe they’re lactose intolerant are actually just responding to the casein A1 in the milk. So, before jumping to conclusions, you could try using raw milk obtained specifically from A2 producing Jersey cows to see if it makes a difference.

You’d have to talk to your farmer or raw milk provider to find out whether the cows are A1 or A2 producers. Holsteins are A1 producers and should be avoided. Using A2 milk would be a good idea even if your child does not show signs of milk intolerance, as the A1 casein can be a problematic lectin. It can, however, be more difficult to find. That said, if you have a choice, I would suggest opting for A2 raw milk. The other alternative is goat’s milk that only has A2 casein.

Hypoallergenic Meat-Based Formula

For a demonstration, see Pope’s video above. Brand recommendations and other shopping tips can be found on WAPF’s website, where these recipes are also listed. There you can also find other variations, including a formula using goat’s milk, as well as instructions for making homemade whey.²¹

Pope also offers shopping recommendations on her website, noting Radiant Life Company sells many the ingredients necessary for milk-based formula.²² The following recipe will yield 36 ounces of formula:

However, a couple of caveats are in order:

Nutrition Facts for Homemade Formula

According to WAPF, their homemade formulas provide the following amounts of critical nutrients per ounce:

The following chart shows how the three homemade formulas compare in terms of other nutrients, and how they stack up against breast milk:

Never Give Your Baby Soy Formula

There are few instances where I make absolute recommendations, seeing how there are usually exceptions to every rule. But when it comes to soy formula, I believe it’s unsuitable for all children. Soy simply has too many negative health effects, both for girls and boys.

Considering we now know endocrine disrupting chemicals found in plastics and any number of household products can wreak havoc on human health, it makes no sense to even consider using soy formula, which contains far higher amounts of estrogenic compounds than plastic containers.

So please, do your best to breast-feed, and if you have to use formula, make your own. While soy formula is one of the worst of the bunch, very few commercial formulas, even organic ones, can compare to breast milk or homemade formula.

Granted, you need to make sure you’re getting high-quality ingredients and following an expert recipe. In my view, WAPF has the nutritional qualifications to craft a well-designed recipe. For further guidance, I recommend joining a local WAPF chapter.²⁴

Articles